New Suffolk

New Suffolk

All Listings Under $100,000 $100,000 - $200,000
$600,000 - $700,000 $700,000 - $800,000 Over $1,000,000
Refine your search to less than 500 properties to save.
Click on the map to draw your polygon search.
Click on the map to draw your radius search.
Search only mappable listings within the map's bounds.

35 Orchard Street, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,800 SqFt
NEW SUFFOLK!! Fabulous Old World Charm, Corner Lot, Neighboring Marina, Sandy Bay Beach, Waterside Dining, Sailboats and Flip Flops. This Home is Ready for your creativity, 8" Wood Flooring, EIK, Screened in Porch, Full Attic, 3 Bedrooms , Living Room, and Dining Room - it's all there. Tons of Light, Great Space, Beautiful Property, w a Detached Garage and Shed. Very Close to the Beach, the Old Red School House, and Low Taxes! Opportunity
Status: Active

515 Third Street, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 1 Bath,
Location! Location! This charming 3 bed 1 bath home is located in historic New Suffolk and just 1-1/2 blocks from beautiful sandy beach. Close to New Suffolk waterfront and restaurants, park, marina and school . This early colonial is loaded with character and still has some of its original details including wide plank wood floors, bead board ceilings etc. With some TLC this home can be a unique summer or year round residence.
Status: Coming Soon (Feb 9th, 2023)

N/A, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 3 Baths,
In the Coveted Hamlet of New Suffolk. Single family home, detached garage and Cottage ready for your vision to renovate/rebuild. Close to beach and Marina. Imagine the possibilities! Sold "AS IS". No representations of appliances or utilities.
Status: Pending

720 2nd Street, New Suffolk

5 Beds, 3 Baths,
Summer in the beautiful hamlet of New Suffolk! Three charming cottages offer a unique space for family or friends to enjoy Summer 2023 simultaneously. Nestled between water views, this property has a meticulously landscaped yard that provides plenty of room to relax and entertain while the separate well-adorned cottages provide privacy and solitude. Just steps away you will enjoy the highly sought-after New Suffolk beach on the Peconic Bay,
Status: Active

189 Old Harbor Road, New Suffolk

4 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,500 SqFt
2023 Rates: April-May 1st: $6,000.00/month; May $12,000.00; June $17,000.00; July $25,000.00; August-LD $28,000.00; MD-LD $65,000.00 ; September 13-30th $6,500.00; October $10,000.00.Pristine Mid Century Modern Bay Front W/ 200' Of Private Sugar Sand Beach! Property Features Breathtaking Views Of Robins Island, Southampton And Nassau Point. Chic Furnishings Adorn This Lovely Home Along W/ Interior Panoramic Views Of The Great Peconic Bay. Open
Status: Active

199 Old Harbor Road, New Suffolk

4 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,200 SqFt
New Suffolk, North Fork BAYFRONT residence. Ideal location to while away the hours and enjoy the North Fork farmstands, wineries and more! Sublime Bayfront With Dock. Home Features quality, high-speed internet in Colonial Revival Charm at the beach... Entry Hall, Broad Waterside Living Room W/Fireplace and Views, formal dinning room, Eik, Den/Br W/Bath and First Floor Master Suite W/Bath; Upstairs 2 Bedrooms and Bath. Private Estate Area
Status: Active

640 Orchard Street, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 2 Baths,
This classic updated 19th century home in the heart of historic New Suffolk is just 4 blocks to one of the North Fork's best bay beaches, plus two renowned local restaurants. It offers stylish living spaces -- living room, den, dining room, eat-in kitchen, 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, central air conditioning. Many antique details and original wood floors add to the charm. The wraparound porch invites summer lounging, as does the spacious
Status: Active

1155 Old Harbor Road, New Suffolk

4 Beds, 3 Baths,
AVAILABLE FALL, WINTER, SPRING! Quintessential North Fork bay beachfront rental. Enjoy the fabulous sandy beach for swimming, paddleboarding and walking. Stunning views across Cutchogue Harbor and Peconic Bay will be yours at this spacious waterfront home, whether from the airy great room, the brick patio, or from your beachside deck. Tucked away down a quiet drive, this home offers peace and privacy in historic New Suffolk. There are 3
Status: Active

1380 Grathwohl Road, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 3 Baths,
"Location! Location! Location! - This nautical themed home is light and airy. It is situated at water front of tidal West Creek, with distant views of the North Fork Country Club. Sunsets are spectacular! The house features a large upstairs MBR suite, with gas fireplace and two balconies. The large bathroom has two sinks, shower and Jacuzzi tub, walk-in closet and laundry shute1st floor open concept living with vaulted ceilings
Status: Active

16640 Main Street # Cottag, New Suffolk

1 Bed, 1 Bath, 470 SqFt
SEASONAL RENTAL AVAILABLE FOR MONTH OF JUNE 2023, and September after Labor Day. Just Two Blocks To A Sandy Bay Beach, This Charming Cedar Shake Cottage Is The Perfect Summer Getaway. The Bedroom Has A Queen Size Bed, The Bathroom Is All New. The Living Room Has A Futon Sofa, And The Spacious Eat-In Kitchen Features Full Size Appliances. A Furnished Brick Patio Runs The Length Of The Cottage, Complete With Gas Grill. NOT available year-round.
Status: Active



Walking the streets of the little hamlet of New Suffolk, one would hardly believe that it was once home to America’s first submarine base and one of the busiest ports in the area.

The submarine USS Holland (SS-1), the first commissioned submarine in the U.S. Navy, along with five other Holland Torpedo Boat Company-designed submarines of the Plunger class, were based in New Suffolk between 1899 and 1905, prompting this claim. First called Booth’s Neck and, later, Robin’s Island Neck, the area was already a busy port long before the Holland Torpedo Boat Company began making submarines for the US Navy.

Although the boat company is gone, replaced by a community park, garden, and café overlooking the bay, the area continues to offer an abundance of aquatic activities. New Suffolk is a popular destination for recreational boating and the small downtown center is the best place to watch the North Fork’s popular Wednesday Night Sailboat races.

New Suffolk still retains its quaint New England charm, with stunning historic architecture and a two-room school house for students in grades K-6. The New Suffolk School District is one of the smallest in New York State.

Information Copyright 2021, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.

Information Copyright 2023, OneKey™ MLS. All Rights Reserved.