New Suffolk

New Suffolk

All Listings Under $100,000 $300,000 - $400,000
$500,000 - $600,000 Over $1,000,000
Refine your search to less than 500 properties to save.
Click on the map to draw your polygon search.
Click on the map to draw your radius search.
Search only mappable listings within the map's bounds.
$2,750,000
 

1295 Old Harbor Rd, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,302 SqFt
Nantucket Meets The North Fork. Rare Bayfront In Sought-After New Suffolk With 120 Ft Of Sandy Beach Features 2 Levels Of Mahogany Decks, Just-Renovated Kitchen, 3 Bedrooms Including A Master Suite That Faces The Sunrise, All Topped By A Lookout Tower With Panoramic Views. Entertaining Spaces Include Water-View Living & Dining Rooms, Den, Screened Porch + Brick Patio. 2 Fireplaces. The Barn Is A Great Potential Studio. Reclaimed Materials,
$1,699,000
 

720 2nd St, New Suffolk

6 Beds, 5 Baths,
Rare, Water View Seaside Compound In The Storybook Hamlet Of New Suffolk! Main House And 3 Seasonal Cottages. In All, 6 Bedrooms And 5 Baths. One Block To Beach, Cafes And Boat Ramp. Bike To Marina, Town And Farm Stands. Most Coveted Spot On The North Fork! Income Potential. Low Taxes.
$1,599,000
 

925 1st St, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 4 Baths,
Exquisite, Sleek And Sophisticated With Water Views. Newly Gut-Renovated And Expanded. Designer's Own Home Features Every Hi-End Amenity. Open Floorplan, With 3 Master Suites. Expansive Indoor And Outdoor Entertaining Areas. One Block To Beach In Coveted Hamlet Of New Suffolk. Bike To Marina And Farm Stands. Near Vineyards, Fine Dining. Most Coveted Spot On The North Fork.
$575,000
 

945 Fanning Rd, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,680 SqFt
Best Value In Coveted New Suffolk! This Mid-Century Home Is On A Quiet Street Close To Sandy Bay Beaches And A Marina. Spacious Layout Features A Sunny Living Room W Fireplace, Dining Room, Eat-In Kitchen W Skylight, 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths. Updated Kitchen W Granite Counters & Stainless Appliances. Natural Gas Heat, Public Water, Central Air. Covered Porch & Patio Face A Very Private Backyard. Very Low Taxes!
$549,000
 

5080 New Suffolk Rd, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 2 Baths,
Wonderful 1940'S Cape In Sought After New Suffolk!! 3Br, 2Ba, Living Room, Formal Dining Room, Spacious Kitchen, Front Sun Porch, Full Basement, Area For Wine Cellar, Detached One Car Garage,Easily Maintained Property.
Reduced
$345,000
 

310 Orchard St, New Suffolk

Build Your Dream Cottage In New Suffolk's Seaside Community. Enjoy Small Town Quaintness In This Picturesque Quintessential Small Town. A Short Distance To Beautiful White Sandy Beach With Boat Launching Ramp And Ample Parking Facilities. Close To Vineyards, Restaurants, And Farm Stands.
$21,000
 

16500 Main St, New Suffolk

6 Beds, 4 Baths,
This 1883 Historic Home Is Completely Renovated & Brilliantly Decorated. Located In The Heart Of New Suffolk, It Offers Great Spaces For Entertaining & Relaxing. 5 Bedrooms, 4 Baths. Less Than 1/4 Mile From Beautiful North Fork Beaches, Local Restaurants, & Public Boat Ramp. The Perfect Location For Your Next Vacation. Cottage On Property Also Available. Rent The Whole Compound For A Large Group, Family Reunion Or Wedding Party. 2
$18,000
 

N/A, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 2 Baths,
Your Perfect North Fork Beach House. 3 Blocks To Sandy Bay Beach In Sought-After New Suffolk. Lovely Gardens W Patio, Dining Area With Bbq, Screened Gazebo, Outdoor Shower. Inside, A Loft-Like Sky-Lit Open Layout Offers Living, Dining, Kitchen, Fireplace, Plus Sunroom. 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths Include Ensuite Master; Media Room. Central Air. Close To Dining, Wineries, Farms.
$15,000
 

N/A, New Suffolk

2 Beds, 1 Bath,
Charming, Lovingly Updated "Mermaid Cottage" In The Historic Maritime Hamlet Of New Suffolk. 2 Bedrooms, One Bath, Eat-In Kitchen, Hardwood Floors, Fireplace, Fabulous Screened Porch, Outdoor Shower. Close To A Gorgeous Sandy Bay Beach, Restaurants And Post Office. Perfect North Fork Retreat.
$14,000
 

165 2nd St, New Suffolk

3 Beds, 1 Bath,
Spend Your Summer Days At This Charming New Suffolk Cottage With Water Views And Just A Short Distance To Restaurants And Small Shops. 3 Bedrooms And 1 Full Bathroom, Living Room, Outdoor Shower And Deck Overlooking The Water. Bi-Weekly Rental Also Considered.
$14,000
 

16500 Main St, New Suffolk

4 Beds, 4 Baths,
This Quaint North Fork Cottage Is Completely Renovated & Brilliantly Decorated. Located In The Heart Of New Suffolk, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Bath. Less Than A 1/4 Mile From Local Beaches, Restaurants, & Public Boat Ramp. Perfect For Your Next North Fork Vacation. Rent Just The Cottage Or The Whole Compound For A Large Group, Family Reunion Or Wedding Party.
$10,000
 

1200 1st St, New Suffolk

4 Beds, 4 Baths,
Sun, Sea, Stunning! Elegant Waterfront Oasis In The Historic Maritime Hamlet Of New Suffolk. Finely-Detailed With Impeccable Taste And Style, This 4 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath Home Offers Spectacular Water Views From Every Vantage Point. Massive Bayfront Deck For Relaxing And Entertaining. Steps To The Beach. Near Restaurants And Vineyards.
$10,000
 

189 Old Harbor Rd, New Suffolk

4 Beds, 3 Baths,
Enjoy This Pristine Mid Century Modern Bay Front W/ 200' Of Your Own Private Bay Beach! This Home Also Features Breathtaking Views Of Robbins Island, Southampton And Nassau Point. Chic Furnishings Adorn This Lovely Home Along W/ Interior Panoramic Views Of The Great Peconic Bay. Open Living Space W/ High Ceilings, Master Suite, 3 Additional Bedrooms, An Eat In Kitchen And 2.5 Baths. This House Has Everything T Enjoy An Authentic Nf Summer
$8,800
 

885 Orchard St, New Suffolk

1 Bed, 1 Bath,
Charming Beachfront Cottage In The Bayfront Hamlet Of New Suffolk. Enjoy The Simplicity Of Summer: The Views, The Deck And Garden, And Your Sandy Bay Beach. This One-Bedroom Full Season Rental Is Easy On The Budget Too; Utilities Included.
$8,000
 

720 Second St, New Suffolk

1 Bath,
Bring Your Flip Flops And Move Right In. Adorable Beach Cottage In The Heart Of The Historic Maritime Hamlet Of New Suffolk. One Block To Beach, Local Restaurant. Cottage Features Living Room W Pullout Sofa, Eik, Full Bath. Daydream On Your Covered Porch Overlooking Your Lovely Water View Yard. No Pets, No Smoking.
$5,000
 

720 Second St, New Suffolk

2 Beds, 1 Bath,
Bring Your Flip Flops And Move Right In. Adorable Beach Cottage In The Heart Of The Historic Maritime Hamlet Of New Suffolk. One Block To Beach, Local Restaurant. 2 Bedroom Cottage Features Living Room, Kitchen, Full Bath. Daydream On Your Covered Porch Overlooking Your Lovely Water View Yard. No Pets, No Smoking.

 


 

Walking the streets of the little hamlet of New Suffolk, one would hardly believe that it was once home to America’s first submarine base and one of the busiest ports in the area.

The submarine USS Holland (SS-1), the first commissioned submarine in the U.S. Navy, along with five other Holland Torpedo Boat Company-designed submarines of the Plunger class, were based in New Suffolk between 1899 and 1905, prompting this claim. First called Booth’s Neck and, later, Robin’s Island Neck, the area was already a busy port long before the Holland Torpedo Boat Company began making submarines for the US Navy.

Although the boat company is gone, replaced by a community park, garden, and café overlooking the bay, the area continues to offer an abundance of aquatic activities. New Suffolk is a popular destination for recreational boating and the small downtown center is the best place to watch the North Fork’s popular Wednesday Night Sailboat races.

New Suffolk still retains its quaint New England charm, with stunning historic architecture and a two-room school house for students in grades K-6. The New Suffolk School District is one of the smallest in New York State.

The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use.

Information Copyright 2018, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved.